The Essential Role of Testimonials in Website Design for New Businesses

Why What Others Say About You Matters More Than What You Say About Yourself

Imagine you’re standing at the bakery counter of a small local shop, two loaves of bread in front of you. Both look delicious, freshly baked and golden brown. But one comes with a recommendation from someone who bought it last week – “This is the best sourdough I’ve ever tasted!” Immediately, you’re drawn to that one, right? It’s not just about the bread now; it’s about trust, reassurance, and knowing someone else has already had a good experience.

This simple scenario plays out every day, not just with bread but with every decision people make – including choosing where to shop, what to buy, and which services to use. For new businesses trying to carve a place for themselves in the crowded digital landscape, real recommendations and personal stories from customers hold incredible power. These testimonials, when thoughtfully incorporated into your website, can transform a mere site visit into a trusted connection.

The Power of Stories Through Others’ Eyes

Humans are wired for storytelling. It’s why we stay up late reading novels, binge-watch a gripping series, or listen intently when someone shares their experiences. We connect emotionally to narratives because they feel relatable and tap into our shared humanity. Testimonials, in essence, are stories too.

When someone shares why they loved working with your business or how your product improved their life, it resonates on a primal level. It’s not just marketing jargon anymore. Suddenly, there’s a face – a real person – behind the words. It’s these authentic connections that make people stop scrolling and start paying attention.

Now, let’s think about it this way: as a new business, people haven’t had time to fully trust you yet. They don’t know your story. You haven’t been around long enough to create a household name. But if a past customer can “speak” on your behalf – someone whose experience speaks to potential users – you’re borrowing a bit of their trust. You’re giving prospective clients a reason to lean in and say, “If this worked for them, maybe it can work for me, too.”

Credibility in the Age of Skepticism

The online world is noisy. Every business is promising to be the best; every product claims to be a must-have. People have learned to put their guard up because they’ve been misled by a glossy ad one too many times. Testimonials cut through that noise in a way few other design elements can.

They root your business in credibility. Think about your first customer – someone who took a gamble on your brand. The fact that they believed in your offering and came away satisfied is a testament to the quality of your work. Showcasing their words isn’t boasting; it’s evidence.

But more importantly, testimonials feel human. While stats like ‘100 satisfied clients’ or ‘5-star rating’ contribute to your credibility, they lack the emotional weight of real voices saying, “This business gave me exactly what I needed.” Numbers convince, but stories persuade.

What Happens When We See Ourselves in Others

Have you ever read a testimonial and thought, “That’s me”? Maybe not word-for-word, but you relate. Whether it’s a single mum balancing work and home, a young professional starting fresh in their career, or a retiree embarking on a new hobby, these snippets reflect the lived experiences of other people. Usually, people see their own hopes, challenges, or needs reflected in these testimonials – and that’s where the magic lies.

When potential customers come across a story that sounds like theirs, it sparks an internal dialogue: “If this works for them, there’s no reason it won’t work for me.” This moment of recognition often serves as the final nudge to take action.

That’s why it’s important to include a variety of testimonials. Feature stories from people in different situations, and let their voices echo the diverse needs you cater to. Their diversity becomes your strength, allowing you to appeal to a broader range of customers.

Testimonials as Silent Salespeople

If your website is your shopfront, testimonials are like your best salespeople. They don’t push; they don’t stuff products down people’s throats. Instead, they gently hold the door open, offer reassurance, and tell visitors why your business deserves their attention.

Through testimonials, you’re not just listing the features of your product, you’re showing what those features look like in action. It’s not about saying, “We do X, Y, and Z.” It’s about hearing someone say, “X made my life easier, Y solved a major problem, and Z? Z was just the cherry on top.”

Every testimonial is also a silent success story. It builds momentum for your brand, reinforcing the idea that your business isn’t just about promises; it’s about delivering on those promises.

Where They Belong and How to Showcase Them

When it comes to placing testimonials on your website, it’s not just about having them; it’s about where they are and how they’re presented. Interspersing them throughout your site ensures they’re seen – like a gentle thread weaving together the fabric of your credibility.

Consider placing a glowing recommendation near your homepage banner. Right away, you’re telling visitors, “Here’s what people think about us.” On product pages or service descriptions, testimonials can work as real-life proof, backing up your claims. Even on the Contact Us page, a kind word from former clients may just be the push a hesitant visitor needs to reach out.

But don’t stop there. Add depth by including photos, names, or even short video testimonials if your customers are comfortable. It’s one thing to read an anonymous quote; it’s another to see an actual person sharing their experience. These small touches amplify trustworthiness while adding personality.

Lastly, ensure the design does justice to your testimonials. Keep them clear, easy to read, and visually appealing. The best testimonials lose their power if buried in a cluttered, poorly designed section.

How to Gather Gold Nuggets of Feedback

Here’s the question everyone asks: I’m a new business, how do I even get testimonials to begin with? First and foremost, focus on building relationships with those first customers. They will be your strongest advocates because they were with you before you hit your stride.

When asking for a testimonial, make it as easy as possible. Don’t leave room for hesitation. A simple email like this can work wonders:

“Hi [Name], thank you so much for [specific interaction or purchase]. It’s been a pleasure working with you, and I’d love to hear your thoughts about your experience with us. If you’re happy to share, a few sentences would be wonderful – what you liked, what stood out, and how we helped solve a challenge. Your feedback would mean the world to us and help [business] grow.”

Most satisfied customers will be happy to help, especially when approached personally. You gave value, and now they’re returning the favour.

Building a Foundation of Trust and Community

Testimonials are more than just a website element – they’re the glue that binds trust to design. They remind your audience that you’re not just a faceless brand; you’re a real entity that sparks real joy for your customers.

For new businesses navigating the tricky early years, testimonials play an even more essential role. They’re proof that you belong. That you add value. That your humble beginnings don’t define your capability.

Much like that bakery loaf with a glowing review, a well-placed testimonial can tip someone from “Maybe one day” to “I’m ready to get started.” And once that first leap has been made, you’re no longer unknown. You’re trusted. That’s worth its weight in gold.

Sarah Wu
Digital Strategist & Web Designer
Book A Discovery Call